Saturday 29 September 2018

Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

This is a photo essay of New Zealand's second city (by size) Christchurch which experienced a devastating earthquake in 2011. I used to be a frequent visitor to the central city on a Saturday to wander around the streets and sometimes shop. Since the earthquake I have ventured into town infrequently and generally on a focused trip to a specific place or event, never for a wander around.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

This past Saturday was sunny and I parked the car in the new Lichfield Street car park, close to the shop that used to be my second home Ballantynes and not only met my girlfriend for lunch but wandered around taking photos of the newly emerging city.

The city is definitely coming back to life, and I am torn by the new look city. It does create a strong emotional response: joy on the one hand that the city is rising again and sadness that maybe the rebuild was driven by speed, cost and concrete slab architecture. I wonder if the city missed an opportunity to achieve its full potential and develop a more cohesive look. Maybe I am too influenced by Napier (the Art Deco city) which I just love. Napier had the opportunity to rebuild after the 1931 Hawkes Bay earthquake and was redeveloped with a cohesive Art Deco style. Will Christchurch in 50 years time be venerated or past its prime? I do wonder if the Christchurch of the future will be as polarising as the 1950's Brutalist architecture, of which Christchurch had its own famous exponents. It would be a shame if we had got rid of some truly awful buildings to just create our own for future generations.

Pre quake Cathedral Square: BNZ centre and Government Life Building on the right - truly ugly

The Gateway Bridge

On the way into the city I drive around the airport past the new Gateway Bridge the entrance to the South and the Southern Alps.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The design draws on the vertical power of the Southern Alps and the braided rivers, unique to the Canterbury Plains
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The bridge with its changing colour light show

Map of the city

Christchurch city centre is not large and all the places included in this post are within walking distance of each other, especially given the abundance of places to rest and refuel.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The city and key sights - including Head Over Heels - does even Google know I am a shoeaholic?

Cashel Street

City (Cashel) Mall and High Street in days of yore were the place to shop, then there was the Re:Start container mall which has now been replaced by real buildings.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
View West from the Bridge of Remembrance
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
View East along Cashel Mall, including the Tourist loop tram, Ballantynes on the right.
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
A mainstay of the city centre Scorpio Books now in the BNZ centre
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The BNZ centre
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Cashel Mall from High Street
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
For comparison the imaginatively conceived Re:Start Container Mall which opened on 29 October 2011

"The Strip"

The iconic entertainment mecca for the young is slowly rejuvenating along Oxford Terrace.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Oxford Terrace and the new Strip
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
"The Strip" in yesteryear
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The Strip from across the Avon River
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
South end of the Strip looking towards the Justice precinct

The Bridge of Remembrance

The war memorial dedicated to those who died in World War 1 but also remembering those who participated in both World Wars and subsequent conflicts in Asia in the 1950s to early 1970s.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The Bridge over the Avon River
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The gate looking east
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The gate looking west

Oi Manawa - Canterbury Earthquake National Memorial

Five months after the magnitude 7.1 earthquake, centred just along the road from us (40 kilometres, west of Christchurch), an even more damaging quake struck at 12.51pm on 22 February 2011. The shallow, 6.3 magnitude quake, in the Port Hills just 10 kilometres from the centre of Christchurch, caused the greatest ground acceleration ever recorded in New Zealand.  The quake sequence included more than 11,000 aftershocks.

The earthquake claimed the lives of 185 people and injured many more. About 25,000 houses suffered serious damage and more than half of all buildings in the central city had to be demolished. The memorial, opened to the public on 22 February 2017, on the sixth anniversary of the earthquake. It pays respect to those who lost their lives, those who were seriously injured and survivors. It also acknowledges the support received during the response and recovery that followed.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The memorial inscription
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The memorial wall extends 111 metres along the curve of the Ōtākaro/Avon River
The names of the 185 who died are inscribed into marble panels stretching 40 metres along the memorial wall.  The arrangement of names and how they are written was guided by the bereaved families. All names are in English, as well as the person’s first language (Japanese, Chinese, Korean, Thai, Hebrew, Arabic, Serbian or Russian), if it was not English.

The Arts Centre of Christchurch

The Arts Centre is one of the most significant collections of historic buildings in New Zealand. It is over half way through its $290 million restoration. 

Originally an educational establishment home to what is now Canterbury University, it has some very famous alumni. Dame Ngaio Marsh (loved her mystery novels in my teens),  Nobel prize winning scientist Ernest, Lord Rutherford and Sir Āpirana Ngata, a prominent NZ politician and lawyer, who promoted and protected Māori culture and language.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Looking fabulous part of the newly restored Christchurch Arts Centre
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Part of the old stonework retained in the entrance to the new toilet facilities
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Under construction

Christ Church Cathedral

The increasingly decrepit eye sore that is Christ Church Cathedral now, once the beating heart of the central city.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The Chalice, designed by Neil Dawson, contains forty-two native plant leaf patterns

Colombo Street


Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Colombo Street north (taken from the walkway in the picture below)
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The walkway over Colombo Street between Ballantynes and The Crossing
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Colombo Street south

Building Art

Lots of art has popped up around Christchurch, some of it sponsored by Christchurch City Council, through the Enliven Places Programme. This programme supports regeneration across the city by encouraging the community to transform spaces and leave a lasting legacy.

It would be easy to write a post just about the art around Christchurch streets as many innovative pieces have come to life over the past seven years. As this post is already rather long I have limited myself to two examples.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
On the wall of a building at Cathedral Junction
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Press Lane artwork by Grace Duval

The stuck in the past

Obviously the biggest stuck in the past is the Christ Church Cathedral which is going to be restored (maybe if someone stumps up enough money). Here are some other buildings around the central city that have some way to go before resurrection.

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Former Municipal Chambers, Oxford Terrace
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Pre earthquake: former Municipal Chambers, designed by Samuel Hurst Seager, built in 1887
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Telephone box outside the former Municipal Chambers looking south towards Oxford Terrace
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Worcester Boulevard just west of Cathedral Square
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
High Street at the east end of Cashel Mall
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Cambridge Terrace, diagonally across the river from the Earthquake Memorial

Hagley Park and the Avon River

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
Cherry blossom time
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?

Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The Avon River in Spring
Creates Sew Slow: Christchurch: A city on the move or stuck in the past?
The waning daffodils

4 comments:

  1. Thanks for sharing your pictures and thoughts about the rising city of Christchurch. The quake was so devastating. Since I live on the east coast of the U.S. New Zealand seems so exotic and yet familiar to me. Enjoying your blog, both the sewing and wardrobe posts as well as travel posts. I am an avid reader although I have never commented. Thanks for all you do and share.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your supportive words. I completely understand reading is easy and enjoyable but taking the next step to reply is harder often because I don't feel I have anything useful to say.

      Delete
  2. Thank you so much for the photo essay. I have never been to your country and I was really engaged with the photographs. It is sad to see the loss of older buildings, with all their organic history. Change, especially devastating change, is hard.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I enjoyed wandering around despite my mixed feelings about the rebirth. Not all buildings were worth saving yet they represented the city's development over time. But is the character I felt was missing born from its buildings or its people? Is this how Napier residents felt about their city in the 1930's? A city we celebrate today.

      Delete